Where the traditions meet
Common ground
Buddhism, yoga, Taoism and Indigenous nations each tend breath, seasons, plants and food. Here is where they meet, and where they don't.
At a glance
01Breath is the bridge
Every tradition here trains the breath. The real split is whether you steer it or let it be.
Start by just noticing the breath
The Buddha's teaching on breathing begins simply: sit, notice whether each breath is long or short, feel the whole body, and let it calm. That's step one of sixteen, and it's enough to start.
Anapanasati Sutta, trans. Thanissaro Bhikkhu
Read more →Shape it on purpose, with a teacher
Yoga's pranayama deliberately paces and holds the breath. A review of 68 studies found possible benefits for the nervous system, lungs and thinking, but many studies were weak. Learn retention and forceful breathing from a trained teacher.
Saoji et al., Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine, 2019
Breathe naturally while you move
Tai chi pairs slow, flowing movement with deep, natural breathing and attention resting on how the body feels. It's best known for helping balance and, in some studies, preventing falls.
Harvard Health
Know that breath means more than air here
In Chinese thought, qi is the basic stuff of existence, and yin and yang are forms of qi whose interplay makes things happen. Taoist texts like the Laozi and Zhuangzi work inside this frame.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Pick one approach and be honest about it
Zen says don't control the breath: long stays long, short stays short. Pranayama shapes it on purpose. Both are old and both are clear about their aims, so practice one at a time rather than blending them.
Soto Zen
Read more →02Medicine and spirit grew up together
Each healing system shares a vocabulary with a contemplative path. Shared roots, not one system.
See yoga and Ayurveda as cousins
Samkhya philosophy counts 25 realities, from the conscious self down to five gross elements. Classical yoga takes its dualism and adds a Lord; Samkhya ideas also show up in early Ayurvedic texts.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Read more →Understand the three doshas from the ground up
Ayurveda builds on older Indian schools of thought: five elements combine into three doshas, vata, pitta and kapha, and health means keeping them in balance.
Jaiswal and Williams, Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine, 2016
Read Chinese medicine through yin and yang
The Yellow Emperor's classic maps yin-yang onto the body: organs that store are yin, organs that transform are yang. It was likely compiled around the first century BCE, and Daoists read it as much as doctors did.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; dates disputed
Know Tibetan medicine is Buddhist medicine
Sowa Rigpa rests on five elements, three dynamics (Lung, Tripa, Pekan) and the Four Tantras, said by tradition to be taught by the Buddha. Bon and Tibetan Buddhism shaped it; UNESCO recognized its medicinal bathing in 2018.
UNESCO; Rubin Museum
Read more →03Live with the seasons where you are
Each tradition reads the year of its own place. Borrow the habit, not the calendar.
Let your habits shift with the year
Every tradition here asks you to eat, sleep and work in step with the season where you live. What differs is the count of seasons, where the year starts, and what marks each turn.
Our summary of the sources in this section
Tune your spirit to the season, Chinese-style
The second chapter of the Yellow Emperor's Basic Questions is about regulating the spirit to match the qi of the four seasons. The idea: what fits spring doesn't fit winter.
Unschuld translation, University of California Press, 2011
Eat and rest for six seasons, Ayurveda-style
Ayurveda splits the year in two: a drying, draining half as the sun moves north, and a cooler, strengthening half as it moves south, with diet and habits changing across six seasons.
Thakkar et al., Ayu, 2011
Read more →Count the year by what the land is doing
The Ojibwe thirteen-moon calendar from White Earth Tribal and Community College starts at the spring equinox with maple sap and names each moon by what happens in nature, through the ricing moon. Names vary by region.
White Earth Tribal and Community College
Cook from your own land
Owamni, Oglala Lakota chef Sean Sherman's Minneapolis restaurant, cooks seasonal Indigenous food and leaves out colonial staples like wheat flour, cane sugar, dairy, beef, pork and chicken. A clear example of eating from place.
Indian Country Today
04Elements: don't line them up
Five phases, five great elements, four roots. Similar counts, different ideas.
Read the Chinese five as verbs
Water, fire, wood, metal and earth name kinds of activity more than substances. By the Han dynasty they had merged with yin-yang into one view of the cosmos.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Read the Indian five as layers
Space, air, fire, water and earth. In Samkhya each grows out of a subtle sense quality, starting with sound for space. Ayurveda pairs seasons with their leading elements, like fire and air in summer.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Ayu, 2011
Read the Greek four as forces
Empedocles named fire, earth, air and water, moved by Love, which blends, and Strife, which separates. He was also remembered as a healer.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Read more →Place Tibet with India, not China
Tibetan medicine's five elements come from the Indian list, not the Chinese one.
UNESCO
Resist matching them one to one
Wood and metal have no place in the Indian list; space has none in the Chinese or Greek. Forcing a match erases what each system was built to explain. Learn each on its own terms.
Our note
05Treat plants and food as relatives
Reciprocity, careful records and conservation: three ways of owing plants something.
Read Braiding Sweetgrass
Robin Wall Kimmerer, a botanist and Citizen Potawatomi Nation member, joins plant science with Indigenous knowledge and asks you to give back to the living world that feeds you. The best single place to start.
Milkweed Editions
Read more →Harvest honorably
Ask permission. Never take the first or the last. Take only what you need, use everything, share, give thanks and give something back. Kimmerer learned it as "responsibility before the taking".
Kimmerer, YES! Magazine; Emergence Magazine
Take a third at most
The Citizen Potawatomi Nation names tobacco, cedar, sage and sweetgrass as sacred medicines. A community gardener there asks harvesters to offer tobacco, ask permission and take no more than a third of a patch.
potawatomi.org, 2019
Buy cultivated, not wild, for at-risk plants
American ginseng, goldenseal, black cohosh, white sage, osha and slippery elm are all under pressure in the wild. Choose farmed sources whenever you can.
United Plant Savers
Read more →Back Native control of Native food
NATIFS, founded by Sean Sherman in 2017, and the Native American Food Sovereignty Alliance work to return control of food systems to Native communities. Supporting them ties food to self-determination.
NATIFS; First Nations Development Institute
06Practice: sitting and moving
Posture, attention and breath show up everywhere. The goals behind them differ.
Sit like a Zen student
Sit upright, chin in, ears over shoulders, hands in the cosmic mudra, eyes half open and lowered. Don't fix on anything; when thoughts come, neither chase them nor push them away.
Soto Zen
Read more →Walk with your breath
Match steps to breath, maybe two or three steps breathing in and three or four breathing out, with your attention on your feet touching the ground.
Plum Village
Read more →Choose a tai chi teacher by word of mouth
Tai chi is very safe, but there's no standard training or license for instructors. Ask about their experience and go on recommendations from people you trust.
Harvard Health
Know what yoga is actually for
In classical yoga, practice exists to tell the conscious self apart from nature. That's a different goal from Zen sitting or tai chi as health practice, so don't assume they're interchangeable.
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Keep what carries across
An upright, relaxed body, steady attention and an unforced breath run through all of these. The reasons behind them don't, so learn each practice on its own terms.
Our summary
07Respect, and borrowing well
Learn from living people, on their terms. Ceremonies belong to those who hold them.
Think twice before buying white sage
The Gabrieleno Band of Mission Indians says much white sage for sale is poached from Southern California wildlands. Check that it's farmed, smudge rarely, skip feathers and shells, or burn incense instead.
Gabrieleno Band of Mission Indians
Read more →Look to your own people's plants
The Gabrieleno ask non-local Indigenous people to use their own nation's plants. The Potawatomi and Gabrieleno agree: know where a medicine plant came from, take little, and don't turn another nation's ceremony into a routine.
Gabrieleno; Citizen Potawatomi Nation
Be wary of anyone selling ceremony
After the 2009 Sedona sweat lodge deaths, Arvol Looking Horse, Keeper of the Sacred White Buffalo Calf Pipe Bundle, wrote that leaders earn the right through long training, and that charging fees corrupts healing.
Indian Country Today
Watch Saging the World
A short documentary by Rose Ramirez and Deborah Small with the California Native Plant Society on white sage poaching. A quick way to see the problem from the people closest to it.
Dominican University of California
Buy Ayurvedic medicines from tested sources
About 1 in 5 Ayurvedic medicines bought online contained lead, mercury or arsenic, partly from the practice of combining herbs with metals. Choose tested products and tell your doctor what you take.
Saper et al., JAMA, 2008
Read more →Borrow the right way
Read Indigenous authors and nations in their own words. Learn from living teachers who invite you, pay for teaching when asked, and practice what's offered openly, not ceremonies a community holds as its own.
Our guidance, drawn from the sources above
08The four directions
The pattern: one day of sun, east to north, read three ways at once: as a day, a year and a life.
Sunrise in the east, midday sun to the south (north of the equator), sunset in the west, night to the north. Many cultures lay that one daily path over the year (spring to winter) and over a life (birth to elderhood). The table shows the common pairing; each nation keeps its own version.
- DirectionSunSeasonLife
- EastSunriseSpringBirth, beginnings
- SouthMiddaySummerYouth, growth
- WestSunsetAutumnAdulthood, harvest
- NorthNightWinterElders, rest
The life pattern, in an Elder's words
Elder Lillian Pitawanakwat walks the circle: east is spring and birth, south summer and youth, west the harvest and adulthood (the berry stage), north winter and elderhood, a time of rest and wisdom.
Anishinaabe (Ojibwe and Potawatomi) teaching, Four Directions Teachings
Same four directions, different colors
A Mi'kmaw teaching says each Nation was given its own understanding of the wheel, so colors and order differ and none is wrong. Mi'kmaw: east white, south yellow, west red, north black, each with an animal, medicine and element.
Mi'kmaq Spirit
'Medicine wheel' is a settlers' name
Settlers first used it for the Bighorn stone circle in Wyoming; over 70 stone wheels are known on the northern Plains. As a teaching circle, how it's used and colored depends on the community.
Saagajiwe, Toronto Metropolitan University
The pattern, set in mountains
In Diné (Navajo) teaching, First Man and First Woman placed four sacred mountains around the homeland: Blanca Peak east, Mount Taylor south, the San Francisco Peaks west, Mount Hesperus north, each with its own color and stone.
Natural History Museum of Utah, with Navajo Nation guidance
The pattern, as seasons and elements
China's Four Symbols: Azure Dragon in the east (spring, wood), Vermilion Bird south (summer, fire), White Tiger west (autumn, metal), Black Tortoise north (winter, water). A Yellow Dragon at the center can complete the five phases.
Four Symbols (encyclopedia)
The directions as guardians
In Hindu tradition the dikpalas guard the directions: Indra the east, Yama the south, Varuna the west, Kubera the north, with four more at the corners. Look for them carved on the walls and ceilings of Hindu and Jain temples.
Guardians of the directions (encyclopedia)
The directions as gates
A Tibetan Buddhist mandala is a square palace with a gate facing each direction; in the Kalachakra mandala the gates link to the Four Noble Truths. Today's mandalas often color the quarters blue east, yellow south, red west, green north.
Michael Henss, Rubin Museum of Art
The year as a wheel
Many Pagans today keep eight festivals: the two solstices, two equinoxes, and Samhain, Imbolc, Beltane and Lughnasadh. The parts are old, but the eight-spoke pattern was put together in the 1950s.
RE:ONLINE, Culham St Gabriel's
With respect. These are living traditions, not a menu. Learn each from the people who keep it: a nation's own elders, cultural centers and tribal colleges. Don't copy ceremonies, sell sacred items or blend teachings into one. Noticing the sun's path is open to everyone.
09Going further
Plant medicine, the I Ching and tarot, and ritual.
- 01Plant medicineWhat the research and the law actually say about psilocybin, ayahuasca, peyote and MDMA, who should stay away, and where to find support.
- 02Tarot and the I ChingTwo old ways of asking a question, where they came from, how people use them now, and what they can and cannot do.
- 03Ritual and the yearWhy people mark time with ritual, the turning points of the sun and moon, and festivals from many cultures that give the year a shape.
- 04Happiness and meaningHappiness is a skill you build, not a mood you wait for. Arthur C. Brooks's playbook: enjoyment, satisfaction and meaning, a handle on your emotions, and the four pillars that hold a good life up.
Sources (22)
accesstoinsight.org · doi.org · iep.utm.edu · harvardhealth.org · sotozen.com · en.wikipedia.org · ich.unesco.org · rubinmuseum.org · muse.jhu.edu · wetcc.edu · ictnews.org · plato.stanford.edu · milkweed.org · dailygood.org · emergencemagazine.org · potawatomi.org · unitedplantsavers.org · natifs.org · plumvillage.org · gabrieleno-nsn.us · dominican.edu · firstnations.org